Cocoa powder is one of the widest accepted choices for giving chocolate desserts the sweet flavor almost everybody loves. It is used in cakes, brownies, puddings, and even ice cream. The tasty ingredient can be substituted with a couple of things, including protein powder.
Table of Contents
How to replace cocoa powder with protein powder
Cocoa is used to give the flavor, scent and look to different types of delicious pastries. That means if I’s replaced or partially substituted, its place needs to be taken by something of similar taste or quality. So, if you want the cocoa-like taste, you’ll need to replace it with either flavored protein powder, or unflavored protein powder in combination with other ingredients.
Using unflavored protein powder as a partial substitute for cocoa powder
Cocoa can also be partially substituted by unflavored protein, but for the taste to remain similar it is extremely important to add another ingredient as strong as the cocoa powder to the mix.
The recommended ingredients to mix with unflavored protein powder are chocolate chips, melted dark chocolate, unsweetened baking chocolate or carob powder. An adequate ratio would be 2:1 in favor of the other ingredient. Which means for every 25 grams of protein powder, you should add 50 grams of carob powder, for example.
You can follow a regular recipe and choose one of the ingredients mentioned above to mix with unflavored protein powder. Just make sure you use the right amounts to substitute the cocoa powder.
Replacing cocoa powder with chocolate flavored protein powder
Chocolate flavored protein powder can completely replace cocoa powder in baked goods; however, it won’t achieve exactly the same taste. The result can be better or worse, depending on your personal preferences but cocoa powder has a specific bitter taste that most protein powders lack.
In the case of using flavored protein powder, different variations of chocolate flavored protein powders are the best choice. Decide between whether you want to fully substitute cocoa powder with protein or mix it with another chocolate chips, dark chocolate or carob powder.
The only difference here is that the ratio between the two cocoa powder substituting ingredients would be 1:1 instead of 2:1. For every 25 grams of protein powder, add 25 grams of one of the other ingredients (carob powder, baking chocolate, dark chocolate chips)
If using baking chocolate, 6 tablespoons of cocoa powder should be replaced by 30 grams of chocolate combined with 25 grams of protein powder.
Coffee lovers should also read this.
Frequently asked questions about cocoa substitutes
Aside from protein powder, what other cocoa powder substitutes are there?
The most common substitutes for cocoa powder are baking chocolate, dark chocolate, carob powder, hot cocoa mix, and semi-sweet chocolate chips. Chocolate chips usually contain sugar, however, which should be taken into account when mixing together the ingredients. So, decrease the amount of sugar you add to your recipe.
What else can protein powder substitute?
Aside from partially replacing cocoa, protein powder can be used to substitute flour in a variety of baked goods. It can also be used in shakes and all smoothies, replacing eggs, curd or other protein sources used in blended drinks.
How to substitute cocoa if you are allergic
A true allergy to cocoa or cacao is very rare, and in such cases, it is best to consult a medical specialist to determine what kinds of foods are suitable for your diet. Make sure to avoid chocolate chips and chocolate in general and do not use them as a substitute. Flavored protein powder can be used if it is free of cocoa.
User comment about cocoa powder and protein
How To Replace Cocoa Powder in Cookies
If your family is eating regular sugar cookies with butter and jam or if you are serving dessert when you go to a special occasion, then you need to know how to replace cocoa powder in your cookies. Your chocolate cookie recipe should not have any added sugar, but it should use only high-quality cocoa powder. If you use any sugar in your recipe, then it will actually add sugar to the mixture and ruin the flavor and the texture of your cookies. Cocoa powder is what your family needs to enjoy your cookies and desserts.
Best way to substitute cocoa powder
The best way to substitute cocoa powder in your recipes is to use pure cocoa powder without any added sweetener. If you prepare dark brownies with a high-quality cocoa mix, then you may cut back a bit on the amount of sugar in your recipe. A small amount will do. If you have a hard time adjusting to less sugar in your brownie recipe, then you can always add a little extra. In fact, if you use the same amount of chocolate chips as you do for your recipe, then the amount that you add to the mix will be less than the total amount of chocolate chips in your recipe. That is why you need to use high-quality cocoa powder when baking chocolate chip cookies with caramel or other sweeteners. That way, your cookies and desserts will taste great and they won’t have a bitter aftertaste.
A pinch of vanilla or cinnamon to your chocolate chip cookies and brownie recipes
You may also want to add a pinch of vanilla or cinnamon to your chocolate chip cookies and brownie recipes. There is nothing wrong with using chocolate flavored ingredients when making chocolate desserts, and you can also make your own cookies using natural flavors like cinnamon or vanilla. But if you choose to use such natural flavors in your cookies, then you need to use high-quality cocoa powder. You can use ground pure cocoa powder in place of the sugar in your cookies. In fact, cocoa powder can be used for baking recipes too. It is a great ingredient for making shortbreads, cupcakes and cookies.
